They do sound like 2 different songs. I think the same about Rosey and Mick. Even on the album the lyrics and the music of Rosey and Mick sound like 2 different songs together. Not sure what they were trying to achieve. It just about works but I think this song could have been 'countryfied' in more blended way.
Both Rosey and Mick and Everything Reminds me of You are among my all time favourites so it's most likely me being a bit biased to the live versions. But I don't think anyone here would be surprised at that